Council approves bill banning storage of personal items on public property

HONOLULU-  A bill allowing the city to confiscate personal items left on public property for more than 24 hours was passed overwhelmingly Wednesday by the Honolulu City Council by a vote of 8-1.

The measure was introduced in late September by District 6 Councilwoman Tulsi Gabbard. 

During a marathon session of the Council that lasted more than four hours, Gabbard explained the purpose of Bill 54 was to ensure that public spaces remain exactly that — public.

“The clear intent of introducing this bill and Bill 54 as it stands, is to keep our public spaces, our public property and public rights of way clean, safe and open and available for all to use — everyone,” said the councilwoman.

However, homeless advocates and those who live on city streets chided Gabbard and her colleagues for targeting the homeless through the legislation.

“Passage of this mean spirited bill will leave no remaining space on Oahu that I know of where one can survive rent free,” said Denise Snyder, one of about two dozen people who testified against the measure.

“This is cruel and unusual punishment,” added David Cannell, a wheelchair bound man who resides at the Next Step homeless shelter in Kakaako.

Still, many of Gabbard’s colleagues rallied behind her as passage of the bill gained momentum. 

District 4 Councilman Stanley Chang made the analogy of a business attempting to store its merchandise on city property.

“If a retailer for instance decided not to rent out warehouse space and instead set up tarps and temporary structures on public sidewalks, I think we would have a problem with that,” said Chang.

The Hawaii chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union urged that the bill be deferred, not on the basis of having personal property confiscated, but rather on the possible implications on First Amendment rights.

“I am not here to suggest that there is a First Amendment right to have tents or structures that block sidewalks,” said Dan Gluck, senior staff attorney at ACLU of Hawaii.  “Under the plain language of this bill if an individual or a group wanted to have a sign or banner…that person could have the signs and even the clothes and the shoes that the person was wearing confiscated.”

The only council person to vote against the measure was District 7 Councilman Romy Cachola.  Cachola questioned how much the bill would cost city taxpayers and whether the legislation could actually make the homeless situation worst.

“I’m always looking at how to save taxpayers money,” said Cachola.  “We should at least look at better ways to do it.”

A representative from the mayor’s office told council members the legislation should have little impact on city finances, since existing staff and resources would be used for its implementation.

Gov. Neil Abercrombie’s Homeless Coordinator, Marc Alexander, testified in support of the bill, saying it could be used to help direct homeless people to shelters and other available services.

“This particular tool can be used to encourage people to open themselves up to services,” he said.   

Louise Kim McCoy, Mayor Peter Carlisle’s spokesperson, said the mayor has supported the bill since it was first introduced.  She said the bill will be scrutinized by the city attorneys before it’s forward to the mayor for his review.

Carlisle has ten working days to sign the bill, veto it, or allow it to become law without his signature. 

Register to log on and leave a comment

Have a news tip?  Contact Andrew Pereira at 368-7273.  Follow Andrew on Twitter at Khon_Reporter  or on Facebook at www.facebook.com/AndrewPereiraKhon2

See the original article at: KHON2 Local News

<--- Like this post? You know what to do.

Comments are closed.