A city worker alerted Envorwatch’s Carroll Cox of illegal dumping at Mailiili Stream in 2009 and he shared that story with KHON2 viewers.
In June of 2009 257 truck loads of concrete waste were discovered dumped in a conservation watershed in Mailiili Stream.
"Mind you most of the work was scheduled on weekends so what does that tell you, overtime," said Cox.
Wednesday the Department of Health and the city announced they had reached a settlement agreement for violations by the city of the Clean Water Act.
"The $1.4 million settlement amount is going to be directed into practical activities that are going to improve the water quality of the Waianae Coast." said Department of Health Deputy Director of Environmental Health Gary Gill.
Under the settlement, $1.2 million will support water quality improvements and $200,000 will be spent on new projects.
"Rather than just taking taxpayers money from one government and putting it in the coffers of another, that we do something productive with this penalty," said Gill.
"It’s being presented more than what it is, it’s not a punishment, it’s not a fine it’s nothing more than putting a pretty face on something that is terribly wrong and it will repeat itself over and over," said Cox.
The city says it spent nearly $53,000 on overtime for those involved in the dumping. And it cost another $1.3 million to clean up the concrete.
"It is a good template to learn from," said Gill. "It begins with the vigilance of the community itself, being aware of what’s going on in your neighborhood and flagging these concerns and reporting them to the Department of Health."
"They place this document in a celebratory fashion as if we’re supposed to go okay great you did a good job," said Cox. "No they didn’t this is an insult."
Westley Chun, the Department of Facility Maintenance Director said in a statement: "We are satisfied to have reached this settlement with the state DOH.
The Department of Facility Maintenance has improved its procedures to prevent this type of incident from happening again, and this settlement will allow the City to focus its resources on projects that will mutually benefit the City and State, instead of continued litigation.
We look forward to working with the DOH to improve water quality in the Mailiili area and throughout Oahu." He added, appropriate personnel actions have been taken against the employees involved.
The Department of Health says it does not have authority to pursue criminal prosecution, only civil fines and penalties for infractions of the Clean Water Act.
"We struggle fight, make them prosecute or take a legal action, they go through the administrative process but no one gets punished criminally," said Cox. "There’s nothing to celebrate about. This was creative sentencing only to serve the betterment of the city and the state."
See the original article at: KHON2 Developing Stories


