Martin made his comments Wednesday during a Budget Committee hearing after administration officials apologized for failing to tell the Council that the city’s self-imposed 20 percent debt limit had been suspended on October 26 of last year. Council members learned of the administration’s decision after a story appeared February 23 in the Honolulu Star-Advertiser.
“I want to begin by actually repeating an apology that I made to the budget chair shortly after the story about this came out,” said Doug Chin, the city’s managing director.
Chin explained the decision to suspend the debt ceiling was not made in a vacuum and that discussions were ongoing with Council members that such a possibility existed. Chin mentioned several budget communications transmitted to Council members in March of last year.
However City Council Budget Chair Ann Kobayashi told Khon2 there’s a stark difference between talking about the possibility of suspending the debt ceiling and actually going forward with the plan.
“There shouldn’t be shades of transparency,” said Kobayashi. “Don’t talk about transparency if there’s not going to be transparency.”
It was also revealed Wednesday Mayor Peter Carlisle wasn’t notified about the decision to go beyond the 20 percent threshold until he read about it last week. City Budget Director Michael Hansen said he notified Chin in late October through a letter, but failed to inform the mayor. That drew an incredulous response from Councilman Romy Cachola.
"It’s unheard of,” said Cachola. “He should be in the loop every time. And then he criticizes this Council and insulted us.” Cachola was referring to comments made by Carlisle last Thursday that the Council was in fact notified.
Chin emphasized repeatedly during the hearing that the city remains on sound financial footing. He said Honolulu would only go above the 20 percent debt limit in 2014 when government bonds are issued for construction of the $5.3 billion elevated rail project.
Chin also noted the formula to calculate city debt is flawed, since it doesn’t take completely separate funding sources for rail into account.
“If you have a bad formula or an inadequate formula, then what you’re getting is an inadequate result or something that’s misleading,” said Chin.
Under the city’s financial plan for rail transit, all government bonds will be paid off through a half percent surcharge to the state’s general excise tax, as well as a full funding grant agreement from the federal government expected to be worth $1.55 billion.
Once debt for rail is taken out of the equation, Chin says the city’s debt limit remains well below the 20 percent ceiling. The city adopted the limit on debt in 1996 as a way to sure-up the city’s credit rating.
"What you end up is getting a more accurate picture of what’s the affordability for the city,” he said.
Still, it’s obvious the episode has had negative impact on relations between the Council and the Carlisle administration.
"It’s proof that there is this credibility problem and it’s hard to regain the trust,” said Kobayashi.
“It leaves me to believe that from this point going forward, it’s hard for this Council to give any credibility to anything the administration represents before this body,” added Martin.
Chin said Mayor Carlisle had apologized personally to Martin through a phone call.
Register to log on and leave a comment
Have a news tip? Contact Andrew Pereira at 368-7273. Follow Andrew on Twitter at Khon_Reporter
See the original article at: KHON2 Local News


